# Mutual funds vs hedge funds: what's the difference?

Source: https://koshex.com/blog/mutual-funds-vs-hedge-funds · Published 10 November 2024 · 8 min read

A mutual fund sells units to the public, while a hedge fund is a privately placed Category III alternative investment fund. Most investors need at least ₹1 crore for a hedge fund, which may borrow and take positions up to twice its NAV. SEBI's mutual fund rules cap a fund's exposure at 100% of net assets.

## Key takeaways

- SEBI's rules define a hedge fund as a Category III alternative investment fund, which is registered with SEBI and not a mutual fund.
- Most investors need at least ₹1 crore for an alternative investment fund, while SEBI sets no minimum for a mutual fund.
- A mutual fund's total exposure is capped at 100% of its net assets. A Category III AIF may run exposure up to 2 times its NAV.
- A mutual fund may hedge, and may short sell only if its scheme document allows it and it trades through a stock exchange.
- A mutual fund's NAV is calculated daily. A Category III AIF must report its NAV at least monthly if open-ended, or quarterly if close-ended.

A mutual fund and a hedge fund both pool money from many investors and hand it to a professional manager. In India, though, they sit under different SEBI rulebooks. SEBI, the Securities and Exchange Board of India, registers both mutual funds and alternative investment funds.

A mutual fund sells units to the public. A unit is one slice of the fund, and its price is the NAV, which is worked out every day. A hedge fund is a different kind of fund, explained below.

## What is the difference between a mutual fund and a hedge fund?

The difference is the rulebook. It decides who can invest, how much money you need, what the manager may do, and how often you see the fund's value.

A mutual fund is open to anyone and has no SEBI minimum. A hedge fund cannot raise money by a public offer, and most investors need ₹1 crore to get in. It may run exposure up to 2 times its NAV, against a mutual fund's 100%. Exposure adds up a fund's positions in shares, bonds and derivatives. A mutual fund's NAV is calculated daily. A hedge fund has to report its NAV at least monthly if it is open-ended, or at least quarterly if it is close-ended.

Open-ended means the fund has no end date. Close-ended means it runs for a fixed term.

## What is a mutual fund?

A mutual fund is a trust registered with SEBI that raises money from the public by selling units. It invests that money in securities, money market instruments, gold, silver and other assets SEBI permits. A fund house manages the money, and a separate custodian keeps the shares and bonds safe.

SEBI groups mutual funds into equity, debt, hybrid, life cycle and other funds, and index funds and ETFs fall in the last group. An index is a list of companies picked by fixed rules. An ETF, or exchange traded fund, is a mutual fund that tracks an index or a metal and trades on a stock exchange. [ETF vs index fund](https://koshex.com/blog/etf-vs-index-fund) sets them side by side. The full picture of how a fund works is in the [mutual funds guide](https://koshex.com/blog/mutual-funds-investment-guide).

## What is a hedge fund in India?

SEBI's AIF Regulations, 2012 define a hedge fund as an alternative investment fund (AIF) that "employs diverse or complex trading strategies and invests and trades in securities having diverse risks or complex products including listed and unlisted derivatives". A derivative is a contract whose value depends on something else, such as a share.

An AIF itself is a privately pooled fund that is not a mutual fund. SEBI sorts AIFs into three categories:

- **Category I** funds invest in start-ups, early-stage ventures, small businesses, infrastructure and areas the government or regulators see as socially or economically desirable.
- **Category II** funds fall outside Categories I and III and cannot borrow beyond what the rules permit. SEBI names private equity funds and debt funds here.
- **Category III** funds use diverse or complex trading strategies and may borrow or use derivatives. SEBI names hedge funds here.

So a hedge fund in India is registered with SEBI and regulated. It raises money only by private placement, through an information or placement memorandum, and not by a public offer. Each scheme can have at most 1,000 investors, not counting accredited investors. These are people whose income or net worth passes SEBI's test, such as ₹2 crore of annual income. By 30 June 2026, Category III AIFs, the group that includes hedge funds, had raised about ₹2.17 lakh crore, SEBI's data show.

## Mutual fund vs hedge fund: side by side

|  | Mutual fund | Hedge fund (Category III AIF) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Rulebook | SEBI Mutual Funds Regulations, 1996 | SEBI AIF Regulations, 2012 |
| Who can invest | Anyone, through a public offer | Private placement only; Indian, foreign or non-resident Indian investors; at most 1,000 investors per scheme (accredited investors not counted) |
| Minimum investment | SEBI sets none; each fund sets its own | ₹1 crore for most investors; ₹25 lakh for the fund's own employees and directors; the floor does not apply to accredited investors |
| Borrowing | Only to meet redemptions: up to 20% of net assets, for up to six months | With investors' consent, within a limit SEBI sets |
| Total exposure | Up to 100% of net assets | Up to 2 times NAV, short positions included |
| Short selling | Only if the scheme document allows it, through a stock exchange | Short positions count towards the 2 times NAV limit |
| NAV reported | Every business day | At least monthly if open-ended; at least quarterly if close-ended |
| Getting money out | Open-ended schemes pay redemption proceeds within 3 working days (5 for mostly overseas schemes) | Open-ended or close-ended; limits on redemption are in the placement memorandum |
| Fees | Expense ratio (the fund's yearly fee) within SEBI's limits | Set out in the placement memorandum; SEBI's mutual fund expense limits do not apply |
| Tax | The fund's own income is exempt; you pay tax on any gain when you sell | Income is not passed through to investors under section 224 |

Net assets means what the fund holds, less what it owes. Redemption means selling your units back to the fund.

## How much money do you need for each?

A mutual fund has no SEBI minimum, while a Category III AIF may not accept less than ₹1 crore from most investors. The floor is ₹25 lakh for the fund's own employees and directors, and it does not apply to accredited investors. An accredited investor holds a certificate from an accreditation agency. For an individual, one test is an annual income of at least ₹2 crore. The rules also set two tests based on net worth.

Say you have saved ₹5,00,000. You can start a SIP or one-time investment from ₹100 in the Koshex app. A SIP is investing a fixed amount at regular intervals, usually monthly. A hedge fund asks for ₹1 crore, which is 20 times that sum, so ₹5,00,000 cannot go in unless you are an accredited investor.

## Can a mutual fund use hedge-fund strategies?

Partly, yes. A mutual fund can hedge and can even short sell.

A hedge is a position that reduces possible losses on a holding. A futures contract is an agreement to trade at a set price on a later date. SEBI lets a fund hold a share and sell a futures contract on the same share as a hedge. The future must cover no more shares than the fund owns. Such a hedge is left out of the 100% exposure limit explained below. It must not be taken against an existing derivative position.

Arbitrage funds and equity savings funds use such hedges. Arbitrage funds follow an arbitrage strategy with at least 65% in equity. Arbitrage is buying in one market and selling in another to profit from a price difference. Equity savings funds must hold at least 65% in equity and related instruments. You can read more on the [arbitrage funds](https://koshex.com/mutual-funds/categories/arbitrage-funds) and [equity savings funds](https://koshex.com/mutual-funds/categories/equity-savings-funds) pages.

Short selling means selling a share you have borrowed, hoping to buy it back cheaper. A mutual fund may short sell or lend securities only if its scheme document allows it, and only through a recognised stock exchange. The scheme must also disclose the extra risks.

The limits are tighter than a Category III AIF's. A mutual fund's total exposure across shares, bonds and derivatives cannot exceed 100% of its net assets. It may borrow only to meet redemptions or pay out income, up to 20% of net assets and for no more than six months. A mutual fund may not lend money for any purpose. Mutual funds carry risk too, and [risks in mutual funds](https://koshex.com/blog/what-are-risks-involved-in-mutual-funds) covers it.

## How do fees and tax differ?

A mutual fund's fees are capped by SEBI, while an AIF's are set out in its placement memorandum. SEBI's mutual fund expense limits do not apply to an AIF.

The base part of the expense ratio is capped at 0.90% for index funds and ETFs, and the costs of the fund's trades come on top. The [expense ratio guide](https://koshex.com/blog/what-is-expense-ratio-and-why-is-it-important) carries the other caps.

A SEBI-registered mutual fund pays no tax on its own income, so trades inside the fund create no tax for you. You are taxed on any gain when you sell. The rate depends on the type of fund and, for equity-oriented funds (at least 65% in Indian listed shares), on whether you held the units for more than 12 months.

Under section 224 of the Income-tax Act, 2025, Category I and II AIFs pass most income through to investors for tax. Category III AIFs do not get that treatment.

## Where do PMS and SIFs fit?

Two other options sit between a mutual fund and a hedge fund. A portfolio management service (PMS) needs a portfolio manager registered with SEBI and at least ₹50 lakh to start. A Specialised Investment Fund (SIF) is a type of mutual fund scheme SEBI created in 2025. It needs at least ₹10 lakh across all of one SIF's strategies, counted by PAN (Permanent Account Number), unless you are an accredited investor. So a SIF is not a hedge fund.

Our [mutual funds vs PMS and SIFs](https://koshex.com/blog/mutual-funds-vs-pms-which-one-is-better) article compares them in full.

Koshex helps you choose a mutual fund that suits your goal and timeline. [Browse mutual funds](https://koshex.com/mutual-funds).

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the difference between a mutual fund and a hedge fund?

A mutual fund sells units to the public, while a hedge fund is a privately placed Category III alternative investment fund. A mutual fund is open to anyone, SEBI sets no minimum for it, and its NAV is calculated daily. A Category III fund needs at least ₹1 crore from most investors and may take positions up to 2 times its NAV.

### Can I invest in a hedge fund in India?

Yes, through a Category III alternative investment fund, which raises money by private placement. Most investors need at least ₹1 crore. The minimum is ₹25 lakh for the fund's own employees and directors, and it does not apply to accredited investors. Indian, foreign and non-resident Indian investors can all take part.

### Can I start a SIP in a hedge fund?

No. A hedge fund is a Category III alternative investment fund, and most investors need at least ₹1 crore to invest in one. The floor is ₹25 lakh for the fund's own employees and directors, and it does not apply to accredited investors. You can start a SIP or one-time investment from ₹100 in the Koshex app.

### What is the difference between a hedge fund and a private equity fund?

SEBI places them in different categories. Private equity funds fall in Category II, which cannot borrow beyond what the rules permit. Hedge funds fall in Category III, which uses diverse or complex trading strategies and may borrow or use derivatives. Category II funds must be close-ended with a minimum tenure of three years.

### Is a SIF the same as a hedge fund?

No. A Specialised Investment Fund is a type of mutual fund scheme that SEBI created in 2025. It needs at least ₹10 lakh across all of one SIF's strategies, counted by PAN, unless you are an accredited investor. A hedge fund is an alternative investment fund, not a mutual fund.

### Are hedge funds regulated in India?

Yes. A hedge fund is a Category III alternative investment fund, and AIFs register with SEBI under its AIF Regulations, 2012. A Category III fund may borrow only with its investors' consent. Its exposure, short positions included, cannot exceed 2 times its NAV.

*This article explains how things work; it is not advice to buy or sell any investment. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.*
