# Fixed deposit or mutual fund: how returns, risk and tax compare

Source: https://koshex.com/blog/what-has-the-best-return-a-fixed-deposit-or-mutual-funds · Published 16 October 2023 · 10 min read

Neither gives better returns as a rule. An FD pays a rate fixed when you open it, and a bank FD is insured up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank. A mutual fund pays no fixed rate and its value can fall, in return for a chance of more over a long time.

## Key takeaways

- An FD's rate is fixed when you open it, while a mutual fund has no fixed rate and its value can fall.
- Deposit insurance of up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank covers bank FDs only, not company deposits or mutual funds.
- FD interest is taxed at your slab rate every year, while mutual fund gains are taxed when you sell.
- A SIP has no interest rate; the rate in a SIP calculator is an assumption you type in.
- The Nifty 50 fell about 38% between 14 January and 23 March 2020, and ₹1,20,000 in it fell to about ₹73,872.

Neither gives better returns as a rule. An FD pays a rate fixed when you open it, and a bank FD is insured up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank. A mutual fund pays no fixed rate and its value can fall, in return for a chance of more over a long time.

So the useful question is what you are trading. One side gives you a known number. The other gives you a range of outcomes, some below what you put in. Tax and time shift the picture too.

## What is the difference between an FD and a mutual fund?

An FD is a loan to a bank or a company at a rate fixed for the term, while a mutual fund is a pool of money from many people that buys shares, bonds or both. A professional manager runs the fund under SEBI rules, and its unit price, the NAV, moves every day.

|  | Fixed deposit | Mutual fund |
| --- | --- | --- |
| What you own | A deposit with a bank or company | Units of a pool of shares, bonds or both |
| How the return is set | A rate contracted when you open it | The NAV moves with what the fund holds; no fixed rate |
| Can the value fall | The rupees you deposited do not fall with the market | Yes, units can be worth less than you paid |
| Who stands behind it | Deposit insurance up to ₹5 lakh, bank FDs only | No insurance; SEBI rules and a riskometer label |
| Tax | Interest at your slab rate (the rate for your income band), every year | Capital gains tax when you sell, by fund type |
| Getting money out | Break early at a lower rate, minus any penalty | Money reaches you within 3 working days; some funds charge an exit load |

The riskometer is the risk label SEBI makes every fund show, on six levels from Low to Very High, checked every month.

## Which has given more over time, and how much more?

Nobody can say in advance, because a fund's return is not fixed and a stretch of losses comes with the deal, while an FD pays exactly its rate. Take ₹1,20,000 kept for five years. Every rate below is an assumption, not a forecast.

- **FD at an assumed 7% a year**, with interest compounding yearly: it grows to ₹1,68,306, which is ₹48,306 of interest. Take someone under 60 whose income apart from this interest is already above ₹10,00,000 under the old regime, or above ₹24,00,000 under the default regime, so all of it is taxed at 30%. With total income under ₹50 lakh there is no surcharge, and tax plus the 4% cess, an extra 4% charge on the tax, comes to ₹15,072 over the five years, leaving ₹1,53,235.
- **Equity fund at an assumed 12% a year**: ₹2,11,481, a gain of ₹91,481. After five years that gain is long-term, meaning the profit comes from units held more than 12 months before selling. Long-term gains on an equity-oriented fund are taxed at 12.5% only above ₹1,25,000 in a tax year, so there is no tax on this one if you have no other long-term equity gains that year.
- **The same fund at an assumed 8%**: ₹1,76,319, with the same no-tax outcome on a gain of ₹56,319.

Here an equity-oriented fund keeps at least 65% in shares of Indian listed companies.

Against the FD's ₹1,53,235 after tax, the fund is ₹58,246 ahead at 12% and ₹23,084 ahead at 8%. The gap shrinks as the assumed rate drops, so the answer is only as good as the rate you type in. AMFI, the body for fund houses, tells its members that illustrations must not show returns above the rate it prescribes for the matching index, which is 12.42% for the Nifty 50. We follow that: 12% and 8% sit below it. Past performance may or may not be sustained in future, and it is not a promise of any future return.

Try your own numbers in the [FD calculator](https://koshex.com/calculators/fixed-deposit-calculator) and the [lumpsum calculator](https://koshex.com/calculators/lumpsum-calculator). A lumpsum is one larger amount invested at one time. [How inflation affects a fixed deposit](https://koshex.com/blog/how-does-inflation-affect-fixed-deposit) has its own article.

## Which is riskier, an FD or a mutual fund?

A mutual fund's value can fall, sometimes sharply, while a bank FD's rupees do not fall with the market and are insured up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank. The insurer, DICGC, covers principal and interest together, for bank deposits only. Company deposits have no such cover, and nor do mutual funds.

Here is what a fall looks like in rupees. The Nifty 50 closed at 12,362.30 on 14 January 2020 and at 7,610.25 on 23 March 2020, a fall of about 38%. ₹1,20,000 in the index on the first date was worth about ₹73,872 on the second. Its first close at or above the January level came on 9 November 2020, at 12,461.05, when the same money was worth about ₹1,20,959. This is a price index, so it leaves out costs and tax, and it is not any fund's result. Selling on 23 March 2020 would have turned a paper fall into a real loss.

A fund's risk depends on what it holds. Over the same weeks, an NSE index of 10-year government bonds, which includes interest, rose about 3%. That is a bond index, not any debt fund.

AMFI's standard risk factors say mutual fund schemes do not promise a return, their value may go up or down, and you can lose part of the money you put in. For more, read [the risks involved in mutual funds](https://koshex.com/blog/what-are-risks-involved-in-mutual-funds), [whether a mutual fund can drop to zero](https://koshex.com/blog/can-mutual-fund-investment-drop-to-zero) and [the safest investments in India](https://koshex.com/blog/what-are-the-safest-investments-with-high-returns-in-india).

## How are FD interest and mutual fund gains taxed?

FD interest is added to your income and taxed at your slab rate every year, while mutual fund gains are taxed when you sell, at rates that depend on the fund type and how long you held.

For FDs:

- If you follow the accrual basis, FD interest is taxed every year as it is earned, even if a cumulative FD pays out only at the end.
- A bank deducts 10% TDS, tax taken off before the money reaches you, once your FD interest from it crosses ₹50,000 in a year. For senior citizens the limit is ₹1,00,000. If your total income is not taxable, you can give the bank a declaration to stop the deduction.
- If you are 60 or older and use the old regime, section 153 (the old Section 80TTB) lets you deduct up to ₹50,000 of interest from bank, co-operative bank and post office deposits. It does not cover company deposits, and the new regime has no such deduction.

For mutual funds:

- An equity-oriented fund's gain on units held 12 months or less is taxed at 20%. A gain on units held longer is taxed at 12.5% on the part above ₹1,25,000 in the tax year.
- Specified Mutual Fund units, from a debt fund with more than 65% in debt and money market instruments, are taxed at your slab rate whatever the holding period if bought on or after 1 April 2023. The holding period is how long you have owned a unit.
- A resident's redemption gains carry no TDS.

A debt fund's gain is taxed only when you sell. These rates are for a resident individual in tax year 2026-27 under the Income-tax Act, 2025, with 4% cess on top.

A tax-saving FD and an ELSS fund (the tax-saving fund with a three-year lock-in) both count towards section 123 (the old Section 80C), under the old regime only. The tax-saving FD's interest is still taxable.

Longer reads: [how fixed deposits are taxed](https://koshex.com/blog/everything-you-need-to-know-about-taxation-on-fixed-deposits) and [tax on mutual fund redemption](https://koshex.com/blog/tax-on-mutual-fund-redemption).

## How quickly can you get your money out of each?

Fund redemptions reach your bank within 3 working days, and a bank FD of up to ₹1 crore can be broken early, but each route can cost you something. For schemes with at least 80% in overseas investments the limit is 5 working days.

On the fund side, some funds charge an exit load, a fee for selling within a set time after buying. ELSS, the tax-saving fund, has a lock-in, a period when you cannot sell at all: three years from the date each unit is allotted, so each SIP instalment has its own three years.

On the FD side, you get the lower rate for the shorter period you stayed, minus any penalty the bank told you about when you opened it. See [how to avoid the penalty on premature withdrawal](https://koshex.com/blog/how-to-avoid-penalty-on-premature-withdrawal-of-fixed-deposit) and [exit load in mutual funds](https://koshex.com/blog/exit-load-in-mutual-funds).

## SIP or FD: how do they compare?

A SIP puts a fixed amount into a fund every month at that day's NAV and has no interest rate, while an FD takes one lump sum at a rate fixed in advance. The rate in a SIP calculator is an assumption. The bank's monthly counterpart is a recurring deposit, a deposit you add to every month, covered in [what is a recurring deposit](https://koshex.com/blog/what-is-a-recurring-deposit).

Here is ₹10,000 a month for 60 months, so ₹6,00,000 put in. The rates are assumptions again.

- **SIP at an assumed 12% a year**: ₹8,24,864, which is ₹2,24,864 more than you put in. This follows the method of our [SIP calculator](https://koshex.com/calculators/sip-calculator): the annual rate divided by 12, compounded monthly.
- **SIP at an assumed 8%**: ₹7,39,667.
- **Recurring deposit at an assumed 7% a year**, compounding quarterly: ₹7,19,328, which is ₹1,19,328 of interest. Try it in the [recurring deposit calculator](https://koshex.com/calculators/recurring-deposit-calculator).

The recurring deposit figure does not change with the market. The SIP figure changes with every rate you assume, and a SIP's value can end below the amount invested. Neither figure includes tax. If you sold everything at the five-year mark, the last twelve instalments in an equity-oriented fund would be short-term. The RD's interest is taxed at your slab rate, each year as it accrues if you follow the accrual basis. See [how SIP returns are taxed](https://koshex.com/blog/how-sip-returns-are-taxed) and [what a SIP is](https://koshex.com/blog/systematic-investment-plan-sip).

## How do you decide between an FD and a mutual fund?

Start from when you need the money and how big a fall you could sit through before then. The shorter and surer the date, the more a fixed rate matters. The longer the time, the more room a fund's ups and downs have to even out, though nothing promises that they will.

The factors are the time to the goal, whether part of the money may be needed early, your tax slab, and how a moving value sits with you.

For a goal about a year away, see [investing for the short term](https://koshex.com/blog/looking-to-invest-for-the-short-term-heres-how-to-do-it). Two closer comparisons are [debt funds against fixed deposits](https://koshex.com/blog/debt-mutual-funds-vs-fixed-deposits) and [liquid funds against fixed deposits](https://koshex.com/blog/liquid-funds-vs-fixed-deposits).

Koshex, an app run by an AMFI-registered mutual fund distributor, helps you choose a fund that suits your goal and timeline. A distributor is a registered intermediary that helps you buy and manage funds, and the regular plan is the version you buy through one. See [mutual funds on Koshex](https://koshex.com/mutual-funds).

Koshex offers fixed deposits, bank and corporate, from ₹10,000. See [fixed deposits on Koshex](https://koshex.com/fixed-deposit).

## Frequently asked questions

### Which gives better returns, an FD or a mutual fund?

Neither gives better returns as a rule. An FD pays the rate fixed when you open it, and a mutual fund has no fixed rate and its value can fall. In our five-year example on ₹1,20,000, a fund at an assumed 12% ends ahead of an FD at an assumed 7%. A lower assumed rate shrinks the gap.

### Can a mutual fund lose money?

Yes. AMFI's standard risk factors say the value of a mutual fund investment may go up or down. You can lose part of what you put in. The Nifty 50 closed at 12,362.30 on 14 January 2020 and 7,610.25 on 23 March 2020, a fall of about 38%. That is a price index, not any one fund's result.

### Is SIP better than FD?

They work differently. A SIP buys fund units every month at that day's NAV and has no interest rate. An FD pays a fixed rate on a lump sum. On ₹10,000 a month for 60 months, a SIP at an assumed 12% grows to ₹8,24,864. A recurring deposit at an assumed 7% grows to ₹7,19,328. Both rates are assumptions, and a SIP's value can end below the amount invested.

### Debt fund or FD: which suits short-term money?

They carry different risks, and a debt fund pays no fixed return. Its bonds pay interest to the fund, which shows up as a rise in the NAV. Gains on Specified Mutual Fund units bought on or after 1 April 2023 are taxed at your slab rate whatever the holding period.

### Which suits spare cash, a liquid fund or an FD?

A liquid fund is a mutual fund, so it has no fixed rate and no deposit insurance. A bank FD pays its fixed rate and is insured up to ₹5 lakh per depositor per bank. Our article on liquid funds and fixed deposits compares the two in full.

### Can my mutual fund go to zero?

In theory yes, but only if every share and bond the fund holds became worthless at the same time. What does happen is a deep fall, and AMFI's risk factors list the possible loss of principal among the risks. Our article on whether a fund can drop to zero goes through it.

### Should I pick an FD or a mutual fund for a goal one year away?

Start from the date you need the money and the fall you could sit through before then. A fund's value can be lower on that date, while an FD's rate is fixed. Breaking an FD early costs some interest, and some funds charge an exit load.

*This article explains how things work; it is not advice to buy or sell any investment. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks, read all scheme related documents carefully.*
