Personal loan or credit card: which costs less?
A credit card costs less only if you pay the whole bill by its due date, because then you pay no interest. If you will repay over months, a personal loan or card EMI costs far less than a carried balance in the worked example. Compare the total cost, interest plus fees, over the same months.
In this guide
Key takeaways
- A credit card charges no interest only if the whole outstanding amount is paid on or before the due date.
- At SBI Card's terms (read October 2026), a carried balance of ₹1,50,000 costs ₹39,024 in interest over 12 equal payments.
- On assumed rates, a 12-month card EMI at 15% costs ₹12,468 and a loan at 13% with a 2% fee costs ₹13,776.
- At SBI Card's terms (read October 2026), paying only the minimum due leaves ₹1,17,708 owed after 12 months on a ₹1,50,000 purchase.
- Compare the total cost or the APR over the same number of months, not the monthly instalment alone.
A credit card costs no interest if you pay the whole bill by its due date. Carry a balance instead and interest runs from the date of each purchase. A personal loan charges interest from the first day, at a rate its loan papers state, plus a processing fee. You get the amount upfront, minus any processing fee.
So the answer turns on one thing: will you clear the card bill in full? This article costs one purchase four ways, using RBI's credit card rules and the published terms of one issuer, SBI Card. Those terms are dated and are not a market rate.
Personal loan or credit card: which costs less?
On the figures below, paying the card bill in full costs nothing. A personal loan or a card EMI costs far less than carrying a card balance.
Take Meera, 34, a freelance designer in Kochi. She buys a laptop and software for ₹1,50,000 and wants to repay over about a year. Carrying the balance on the card costs ₹39,024 in interest at SBI Card's terms (read October 2026). A 12-month card EMI at an assumed 15% a year costs ₹12,468. A personal loan at an assumed 13% with an assumed 2% fee costs ₹13,776.
How does a personal loan charge interest?
A personal loan pays you the amount upfront, minus any processing fee. You repay it in fixed monthly instalments that include interest on the reducing balance.
An EMI (equated monthly instalment) is the fixed amount paid each month that covers interest and part of the loan. What are EMIs and how do they work? covers the mechanics. A personal loan is usually unsecured: you pledge nothing, so the lender relies on your income and credit record.
For new retail loans sanctioned on or after 1 October 2024, the lender must give you a Key Facts Statement (KFS). It is a summary sheet of the loan's terms. Its APR, the annual percentage rate, includes all the charges the bank levies. A fee missing from the KFS cannot be charged.
On a floating-rate loan taken as an individual for a purpose other than business, the lender cannot charge you for prepaying it, at any time. How to get a personal loan covers this in full. You can test your own numbers with the personal loan calculator.
How does a credit card charge interest?
A credit card charges no interest if you pay the entire outstanding amount by the due date. If you do not, it charges interest from the date of each purchase.
A credit card lets you buy now and pay the bill later. It is revolving credit: the card comes with a credit limit approved in advance, and you can keep spending within it while an earlier balance is unpaid. Pay less than the whole bill, even the minimum, and the interest-free period is lost. New purchases are charged interest too until the old balance is cleared. Interest may be levied from the date of the transaction on the outstanding amount, not on the total due.
SBI Card's terms (read October 2026) show how this looks at one issuer:
- The interest-free period can range from 20 to 50 days.
- Unsecured cards charge 3.75% a month (45% a year) from the date of the transaction if you do not pay the balance in full.
RBI sets no ceiling on card interest. Each issuer sets its rates under its own policy, in line with other unsecured loans. These card rules cover commercial banks other than small finance banks, payments banks and local area banks.
The minimum amount due is the smallest part of the bill a cardholder must pay so that it is not treated as an overdue bill. RBI says it must be set so that unpaid interest and charges do not keep adding to the debt.
A late charge, or a report to the credit bureaus as past due, comes only after more than three days past the due date. It applies to the outstanding amount, not the total due.
What does a ₹1,50,000 purchase cost each way?
Paid in full on time, nothing. Carried at SBI Card's rate, about ₹39,024 over a year. As a card EMI or a personal loan at the assumed rates, about ₹12,500 to ₹13,800.
These figures are derived, not quotes. The carried balance is charged SBI Card's 3.75% a month from the purchase date and repaid in 12 equal payments. GST and fees are ignored, and there is no other card spending. The 15% card EMI rate, the 13% loan rate and the 2% loan fee are assumed, not any lender's rates.
| Way to pay | Monthly payment | Interest and fees over the year |
|---|---|---|
| Card, bill paid in full by the due date | ₹1,50,000 once | ₹0 (inside the interest-free period; 20 to 50 days at SBI Card) |
| Card balance carried, 12 equal payments at SBI Card's 3.75% a month | ₹15,752 | ₹39,024 interest |
| Card purchase converted to a 12-month card EMI at an assumed 15% a year, no fee | ₹13,539 | ₹12,468 interest (APR 15%) |
| Personal loan at an assumed 13% a year for 12 months, assumed 2% fee | ₹13,398 | ₹10,776 interest plus ₹3,000 fee, ₹13,776 in all (APR 16.87% by RBI's method on the ₹1,47,000 received) |
On these assumed rates, the card EMI and the loan cost about the same, and the loan's fee makes the gap. On the same assumptions, the carried balance costs roughly three times either one.
Why is paying only the minimum due so costly?
At SBI Card the minimum is the month's interest and charges plus just 2% of the balance, so the debt shrinks by only 2% a month.
Here is Meera's bill at SBI Card's terms, ignoring GST. Her first minimum is ₹8,625: ₹5,625 of interest plus 2% of ₹1,50,000. After 12 months of minimums she has paid ₹92,841 and still owes ₹1,17,708. Of what she paid, ₹60,548 went to interest.
After five years she has paid ₹3,02,930, about twice the purchase price, and still owes ₹44,633. This assumes no other spending on the card.
RBI requires every card bill to warn that making only the minimum payment stretches repayment over months or years, with compounded interest. What is a debt trap, and how do you get out of one? looks at what happens once card balances build up.
Card EMI or personal loan: which is cheaper?
It depends on each one's rate and fees, so compare the total cost or the APR over the same months, not the EMI alone.
Converting a card purchase into EMIs means repaying it in fixed monthly instalments instead of one bill. In Meera's example, the assumed 15% card EMI costs ₹12,468 and the assumed 13% loan with a 2% fee costs ₹13,776. The loan has the lower rate, but its fee pushes the total up. Change either assumption and the order can change.
The two show their cost in different places. Card issuers quote APRs for purchases, cash advances and non-payment of the minimum due, with worked examples. Credit card receivables are exempt from the loan KFS, where a personal loan's cost appears.
No-cost EMI is a separate case. RBI requires the card issuer to show the principal, the interest and any discount that makes an EMI no cost before you convert. An EMI that carries interest may not be called no-cost. What are EMIs and how do they work? explains the idea.
How does each affect your credit score?
Both can raise or lower it, because lenders report to all four credit bureaus. Reports go in as on the 9th, 16th, 23rd and last day of each month.
A credit bureau is a company registered with RBI that keeps credit records and produces your credit report and score. Paying on time shows up in the record either way, and so do late or missed payments.
A card balance also counts through how much of your card limit you are using. Each application, for either product, is recorded as an enquiry. A hard enquiry might temporarily lower your credit score.
What is a credit score? explains what goes into a score. Why is your CIBIL score low? covers how to improve one.
When does each one fit?
A card fits a purchase you can clear in full by the due date. A personal loan or card EMI fits a cost you will repay over months.
The card costs nothing if the bill is cleared on time, and in the example above it costs the most if it is not. A loan or card EMI shows its cost before you commit, in the KFS or the issuer's EMI disclosure.
A purchase that strains the monthly budget is a poor fit for both. A loan against mutual funds or against a fixed deposit is a different product again. Loan against mutual funds and loans against fixed deposits explain how they work.