ETF vs fund of funds: what is the difference, and which suits you?
An ETF is a fund you buy and sell on the stock exchange through a demat account. A fund of funds is a mutual fund that invests in other funds, often one ETF. You buy it from the fund house like any fund. The fund of funds adds a layer of cost and, for gold, a longer tax clock.
In this guide
Key takeaways
- A fund of funds is a mutual fund that puts at least 95% of its assets into other mutual fund schemes.
- You need a demat account for ETF units, but not for fund of funds units bought from the fund house.
- SEBI's 0.90% yearly ceiling for a fund of funds in ETFs includes the fees of the ETF it holds.
- A fund of funds is taxed by what it holds, so check the scheme's documents for how the fund house treats it.
ETF vs FoF is a question about the door you use to buy, more than about what sits inside. An ETF (exchange-traded fund) is a fund whose units are listed and traded on a stock exchange. A fund of funds (FoF) is a mutual fund that holds other funds, and many hold a single ETF. Both can own the same gold or the same index. What differs is how you buy, what the price is based on, and how long you must hold before a gain counts as long-term.
What is a fund of funds?
A fund of funds is a mutual fund that puts at least 95% of its money into other mutual fund schemes. It does not buy shares or bonds itself. SEBI files it under "Other" schemes, next to index funds and ETFs. AMFI lists it under FoF headings, such as "Other Scheme - FoF Domestic". A fund house may run more than one FoF if each holds different underlying schemes.
Funds of funds come in a few kinds:
- One-ETF FoFs. They hold a single ETF, such as a gold ETF, a silver ETF or an index ETF. They do not track an index themselves.
- Overseas FoFs. SEBI's sub-types include country-specific, region-specific and sector-based equity FoFs, and debt FoFs. Others mix domestic and overseas funds, with at least 35% on each side. See international funds.
- Several-fund FoFs. A hybrid FoF mirrors a hybrid category's ranges, such as 65–80% in equity-oriented schemes for the aggressive version. A multi-asset allocation FoF keeps at least 10% each in equity-oriented, debt-oriented and commodity-based schemes.
- Gold-plus-silver FoFs. One that holds both gold and silver ETFs is a "Commodity based FoF (Domestic)", passive only, one per fund house.
How ETFs work in detail is in the ETF explainer.
ETF or fund of funds: what is the difference?
An ETF is bought from other investors on the stock exchange. A FoF that holds the same ETF is bought from the fund house at its NAV. NAV is the price of one unit of a fund.
You need a demat account to trade ETF units on an exchange. A demat account holds your units in electronic form. For FoF units you do not need one, because you deal with the fund house. The demat account guide covers the rest.
| ETF | FoF that holds that ETF | |
|---|---|---|
| Where you buy | Stock exchange, in market hours | From the fund house, like any mutual fund |
| Demat account | Yes | No |
| Price | Market price, moving through the day | One NAV, published by 10 am on the next business day |
| What sets the value | What the ETF holds | The ETF's closing price on the exchange |
| SIP with the fund house | No; the fund house deals directly only above ₹25 crore | As the scheme allows |
| Yearly fee ceiling | 0.90% of daily net assets | 0.90%, including the ETF's own fee |
| Selling | To a buyer on the exchange | Redeem to the fund; money within 3 working days |
| Long-term after | 12 months (listed unit; not debt ETFs, see tax section) | 24 months if not equity-oriented |
Funds with at least 80% in overseas investments have five working days to pay redemption money. A fund of funds can also charge an exit load, a fee for selling within a set time. Market makers and the discount rules for ETFs are covered in ETF vs index fund.
A domestic FoF follows the usual rule: money that reaches the fund by 3 pm on a business day gets that day's NAV. Overseas funds of funds set their own timings.
What does each cost?
An ETF charges one yearly fee plus your broker's charges when you trade. A FoF charges its own fee on top of the ETF's, within one SEBI ceiling. The yearly fee is the expense ratio: a percentage of your money, taken out of the fund's value.
The ceilings under SEBI's regulations:
- An ETF or index fund: 0.90% of daily net assets.
- A FoF that invests in liquid schemes, index funds or ETFs: 0.90%, including the weighted average fee of the funds it holds.
- A FoF with at least 65% in equity-oriented schemes: 2.10%, again including the underlying funds' fees.
- Any other FoF: 1.85%, including the underlying funds' fees.
So a gold or silver FoF, which holds ETFs, sits in the 0.90% row. The ETF's expenses count inside that figure. The scheme document must also say that you bear the FoF's recurring expenses in addition to the underlying scheme's. The fund house may take no revenue from the underlying fund.
Four gold and silver funds of funds were checked on 31 August 2026. Their regular plans showed base expense ratios of 0.47% to 0.57% a year. The figures come from their fund houses' factsheets.
SEBI sets no exit load for gold or silver funds of funds. Many funds charge a small one if you leave early, from a week to a year, so read the scheme document. There is no entry load on any mutual fund scheme.
How are ETFs and funds of funds taxed?
Each is taxed by what it holds. A listed ETF unit, other than a debt ETF, turns long-term after 12 months. An unlisted FoF unit that is not equity-oriented needs more than 24 months. The holding period is how long you have owned a unit. Gains on units sold within the line are short-term, and gains after it are long-term.
ETFs. A listed security is short-term if held 12 months or less. An equity ETF holds at least 65% in Indian listed shares. Its exchange sale is a trade chargeable to securities transaction tax (STT). For a resident individual in 2026-27, an equity ETF's short-term gains are taxed at 20%. Its long-term gains are taxed at 12.5% above ₹1,25,000 in a year. A gold, silver or overseas ETF that is not a Specified Mutual Fund is long-term after 12 months, taxed at 12.5%. Its short-term gains go at slab rate, the rate for your total income. A debt ETF, one with more than 65% in debt and money market instruments, is a Specified Mutual Fund. Units bought on or after 1 April 2023 are short-term whatever the holding period, taxed at slab rate.
Funds of funds. The rule depends on what the FoF holds, and there are three routes:
- Equity route. Under section 198(8)(i), a FoF is equity-oriented only if at least 90% is in units of one fund traded on an exchange. That fund must itself hold at least 90% in Indian listed shares. A FoF meeting it can be taxed at the equity rates above. Check the scheme's documents for how the fund house treats it.
- Specified Mutual Fund route. Some funds have more than 65% in debt. A FoF putting 65% or more into units of such funds is a Specified Mutual Fund (section 76(5)(b)). Units bought on or after 1 April 2023 are short-term whatever the holding period, taxed at slab rate.
- Everything else (section 197). Units are long-term after more than 24 months, at 12.5%. Short-term gains go at slab rate. Gold and silver FoFs fall here, whenever you bought them, in FY 2026-27. So do international FoFs that put less than 65% into debt-oriented funds, and most multi-asset FoFs.
Many pages still say every fund of funds is taxed like a debt fund; that is not the law in force.
Three more points. Rebalancing inside a FoF, meaning the fund shifting money between its holdings, is not taxed in your hands. There is no TDS, meaning tax deducted before the money reaches you, on a resident's redemption gains. Cess, an extra 4% on the tax, applies. Surcharge, an extra charge on the tax itself, applies only once total income passes ₹50 lakh. For worked rules across fund types, see how SIP returns are taxed.
Gold ETF or gold fund of funds: which route fits?
The gold is the same, so the choice is about the account and the clock. The ETF needs a demat account and has a 12-month tax clock. The FoF needs no demat account and has a 24-month clock. The FoF also carries a second layer of fee.
Here is an assumed example. You put ₹80,000 into gold and sell after 18 months with an assumed gain of ₹14,000. The tax is for a resident individual in FY 2026-27, with total income under ₹50 lakh.
- Gold ETF (listed). Held more than 12 months, so long-term. Tax is 12.5% of ₹14,000 = ₹1,750, plus ₹70 cess, so ₹1,820.
- Gold FoF (unlisted). Held 24 months or less, so short-term, at your slab rate. At 30%: ₹4,200 plus ₹168 cess, so ₹4,368. At 20%: ₹2,800 plus ₹112 cess, so ₹2,912.
Wait past 24 months and both become long-term at 12.5%.
On risk, SEBI scores a FoF by the riskometer levels of the schemes it holds, weighted by their size. The riskometer is the risk label SEBI makes every fund show, on six levels from Low to Very High. A gold FoF therefore inherits its ETF's level. Going by two fund houses' documents of 31 August 2026, gold ETFs read High and silver ETFs Very High.
The FoF's NAV follows the ETF's closing price on the exchange, so it can differ slightly from the gold price. For SIPs, see the gold SIP guide. Details of each category are on the gold funds and silver funds pages. For gold bought in digital form, read digital gold vs gold mutual funds.
When does a fund of funds make sense, and when an ETF?
A fund of funds suits someone who wants an ETF's exposure but invests through a fund house, often by SIP, without a demat account. An ETF suits someone who already trades on the exchange.
The factors that decide it:
- Demat in place. If you already have a demat account and a broker, the ETF is open to you at one layer of cost. If not, a FoF avoids the account.
- SIP habit. A FoF buys from the fund house on the dates its scheme allows.
- Holding time. For non-equity funds, the 12-month and 24-month lines can change the tax by a wide margin, as the gold example shows.
- Cost layers. Read the scheme's expense ratio and exit load, not only the ETF's.
- Several-fund FoFs. One fund does the rebalancing for you. Weigh that against its fee, which the scheme document shows.
A FoF is not automatically passive. SEBI treats a FoF investing in several funds as having an active strategy, and the active vs passive guide explains the difference. For an ETF set against an index fund, see ETF vs index fund.
Koshex's gold and silver lists show funds of funds, which you can buy like any other mutual fund. Gold ETFs themselves trade on the stock exchange and are not on those lists. These are regular plans, the version of a fund bought through a distributor such as Koshex. As a distributor, Koshex helps you choose a fund that suits your goal and timeline. Browse the options under mutual funds.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an ETF and a fund of funds?
Do funds of funds cost more than ETFs?
Can I start a SIP in a fund of funds without a demat account?
How is a fund of funds taxed?
Is a fund of funds active or passive?
Why does a gold fund of funds' NAV differ from the gold price?
Is a gold fund of funds riskier than a gold ETF?
Which day's NAV does a fund of funds purchase get?
Try it on Koshex
Every fund’s numbers explained in plain English, with help choosing.
Browse mutual funds