Is a low NAV mutual fund better? Why NAV doesn't decide your returns
A low NAV does not make a mutual fund cheaper, and a high NAV does not make it expensive. NAV is only the price of one unit. If two funds' holdings rise by the same percentage, the same money grows by the same rupees in both, whatever the unit price.
In this guide
Key takeaways
- NAV is the price of one unit of a fund. A low NAV does not make a fund cheap, and a high NAV does not make it costly.
- Units bought equal your amount divided by the NAV. What your money earns depends on the percentage change in the fund's holdings.
- A SIP buys at each instalment day's NAV, so a lower NAV that month gives more units, not a better fund.
- A fund's NAV falls when its holdings fall. An IDCW option's NAV also falls by the amount of any payout.
- Check the category, the riskometer, the expense ratio, returns against the benchmark and your own horizon instead of the NAV level.
A low NAV does not make a mutual fund cheaper, and a high NAV does not make it expensive. NAV, short for net asset value, is only the price of one unit of the fund. What decides your result is how much the fund's holdings rise or fall, measured in percent.
So a fund at ₹15 a unit is not a bargain next to one at ₹600. Below is the same sum put into both, so you can see why.
Is a low NAV mutual fund better than a high NAV one?
No. The same amount in two funds whose holdings rise by the same percentage grows by the same rupees, whatever each unit costs.
Take two made-up funds. Fund P has a NAV of ₹15 and Fund Q has a NAV of ₹600. You put ₹30,000 into each. Then both funds' holdings rise 6%. The NAVs and the 6% are invented for this example and say nothing about any real fund or any future.
| Fund P | Fund Q | |
|---|---|---|
| NAV when you buy | ₹15 | ₹600 |
| Units you get for ₹30,000 | 2,000 | 50 |
| NAV after a 6% rise | ₹15.90 | ₹636 |
| Your units are worth | ₹31,800 | ₹31,800 |
You own forty times as many units in Fund P, but each is worth far less. The result is identical. Stamp duty is left out here to keep the sums clean.
The reverse holds too. If both funds' holdings fell 6%, each ₹30,000 would shrink to ₹28,200. The unit price never enters the sum.
A NAV under ₹10 is no different. A fund is not cheap because its unit costs little.
What does a fund's NAV actually tell you?
A fund's NAV tells you the price your money buys at and how many units you get. It does not tell you how good the fund is. NAV is the price of one unit, and a unit is one undivided share in the assets of the fund. SEBI's rule is that the NAV is worked out by dividing the fund's net assets by the number of units outstanding on the valuation date.
Net assets means what the fund's investments are worth, plus its other assets, minus what it owes. Every fund works this out on each business day. Liquid and overnight funds do it on every calendar day.
In practice:
- The price your money buys at. For a purchase, the price is the applicable NAV. SEBI says there is no entry load, so nothing is added on top for buying. A tiny stamp duty is deducted from each purchase, so slightly fewer units are bought.
- How many units you get. It is your amount divided by the NAV. ₹30,000 at ₹15 gives 2,000 units.
When you sell, the price is the applicable NAV less any exit load. An exit load is a fee some funds charge if you sell within a set time after buying. For an open-ended scheme, SEBI caps it at 3% of NAV.
The level of a NAV says nothing about quality. For the growth option, the change in NAV over a period is the return. Take two made-up funds: one's NAV went from ₹40 to ₹44 and the other's from ₹400 to ₹440. Both rose 10%. For how to read those figures, see absolute return vs CAGR.
The expense ratio, the fund's yearly fee, is taken from the fund's assets each day before the NAV is worked out. So the NAV the fund publishes already has it taken out. The expense ratio article explains it in full.
Does NAV matter for a SIP?
In a SIP, each instalment's NAV decides how many units that instalment buys, not how good the fund is. A SIP (systematic investment plan) puts in a fixed amount at each instalment. Each instalment is a separate purchase at that day's NAV, with its own allotment date.
When the NAV is lower that month, your fixed amount buys more units. When it is higher, you get fewer. That is arithmetic, not a sign that the fund is better in one month than another. There is no such thing as a "SIP NAV". There is only the fund's NAV on each instalment day.
The SIP guide shows how the units add up over several months. Which day's NAV your instalment gets depends on cut-off times, which the cut-off timings article covers.
Is NAV the same as a share price?
No. A share price moves because buyers and sellers bid against each other. For an ordinary open-ended fund, nobody bids for units. You buy them from the fund house and sell them back to it, both at NAV, which comes from the value of the fund's holdings.
Exchange traded funds (ETFs) are the exception. Their units are bought and sold on a stock exchange at a market price, once they are allotted and listed. SEBI requires each ETF's indicative NAV, the per-unit value of its portfolio at current market prices, to be shown on the exchange throughout trading hours. Set against the price on screen, it shows how far that price sits from the value of the holdings. The ETF article has the details.
Why does a fund's NAV fall?
A fund's NAV falls when the things it holds fall in value. AMFI's standard risk line says the value of a scheme's securities can fluctuate, so the investment may go up or down.
AMFI also lists wider factors, such as interest rates, currency exchange rates, government policy, taxation and political or economic developments.
One fall comes from a payout, not from the holdings. IDCW is a payout from a fund's income or gains. When a fund pays it, SEBI requires the notice to say the NAV would fall to the extent of the payout and any statutory levy. The NAV drops by the amount paid out.
The growth option pays nothing out, so its NAV carries the whole return. That is why a like-for-like return table uses the growth option. The growth vs IDCW article works through a payout.
What should you look at instead of NAV?
Look at what the fund is built to do and what it costs, then at its record, then at your own timeline:
- Category. SEBI's label for what a fund may hold. It tells you what kind of investments to expect.
- Riskometer. The risk label SEBI makes every fund show, on six levels: Low, Low to Moderate, Moderate, Moderately High, High and Very High. It is checked every month and can change.
- Expense ratio. The fund house and AMFI publish it on their websites every day.
- Past returns against the benchmark. AMFI's website shows scheme returns against the benchmark in terms of CAGR for 1, 3, 5 and 10 years and since inception. CAGR is the average yearly growth over a period, as if the fund had grown at the same pace every year. This is history, not a promise.
- Your own horizon. How long before you need the money decides how much a fall matters.
Koshex is an app run by an AMFI-registered mutual fund distributor. It can help you choose a fund that suits your goal and timeline. It can also review your holdings over time and flag changes. The article on choosing a fund for your goals goes through the steps, and five ways to measure fund risk covers risk. You can also browse funds on the mutual funds page.
Frequently asked questions
Should a mutual fund's NAV be high or low?
What is a good NAV for a mutual fund?
Is a new fund at ₹10 a unit cheaper?
Does an IDCW payout reduce the NAV?
Is the NAV calculated after the expense ratio?
What is the NAV of a SIP?
When is a fund's NAV updated?
Try it on Koshex
Every fund’s numbers explained in plain English, with help choosing.
Browse mutual funds