HomeOur StoryMethodologyLearnFAQs

Is buying a house an investment? Renting vs buying, worked out

A house you live in is partly an investment and partly a cost of living. It saves you rent and its price may rise or fall, but loan interest, stamp duty, maintenance and property tax eat into that. Whether buying beats renting depends on the price, the rent, the loan rate and what the money could earn instead.

Published 9 min read

In this guide

Key takeaways

  • A house you live in is both a cost of living and an asset whose price can rise or fall.
  • As of July 2026, the Reserve Bank of India's rules let a bank lend at most 90%, 80% or 75% of the price. The rest, 10% to 25%, is the down payment, depending on the loan size.
  • In the worked example, a ₹75 lakh flat would need to be worth about ₹1.43 crore in ten years to match renting and investing the difference.
  • Under the old regime only, home loan interest on a home you live in is deductible up to ₹2,00,000 a year under section 22. The house must be finished within five years of the end of the year you borrowed.
  • A flat let at ₹22,000 a month on a ₹75 lakh price earns a 3.52% rental yield before costs and tax.

A house you live in is partly an investment and partly a cost of living. It saves you rent, and its price may rise or fall, but loan interest, stamp duty, maintenance and property tax all take a share. Whether buying beats renting depends on the price, the rent, the loan rate and what your money could earn elsewhere. This article sets out the costs, works one example through, and leaves the decision to you.

Is a house an investment or an expense?

Both. A home you live in is something you spend on every month, and it is also an asset whose price can go up or down.

An asset is something you own that has a money value. A flat you let out earns rent. A flat you live in "earns" the rent you no longer pay to a landlord. Either way, what matters is how much owning costs, how much it saves or earns, and what the house sells for in the end.

No article can fix those three numbers for you, so this one shows how to put your own figures in.

What does owning a home cost beyond its price?

The first cost is the down payment, the share of the price you pay yourself, not borrowed. A bank lends the rest as a home loan, and its loan-to-value limit is the share of the house's cost it may lend.

Under the Reserve Bank of India's rules, as of July 2026, banks' limits for individual housing loans are:

Loan sizeMost a bank may lendLeast you pay as down payment
Up to ₹30 lakh90%10%
Above ₹30 lakh, up to ₹75 lakh80%20%
Above ₹75 lakh75%25%

The down payment is worked out on the price of the house. A bank does not count stamp duty, registration or other documentation charges in the cost it lends against, unless the house costs no more than ₹10 lakh. So you pay those from your own money, on top of the price.

Stamp duty and registration charges are set by each state and differ from state to state, so check your state's registration department for the current rate. Stamp duty, registration and other charges are covered in their own article.

If the price is ₹50 lakh or more, you as buyer deduct 1% TDS and pay it to the government. TDS, tax deducted at source, is tax taken out before the money reaches the seller.

After that, costs run for as long as you own the home:

  • Loan interest, the fee the bank charges for lending you the money.
  • Maintenance, the upkeep of the flat and the building.
  • Property tax, the city's yearly charge on the property.

Koshex also offers home loans.

The EMI, the fixed monthly payment that repays a loan with interest, covers the interest and part of the principal, the amount you borrowed. For how the EMI splits, try the home loan calculator.

What does a home give back?

The rent you stop paying, any rise in the price when you sell, and, under the old tax regime only, some tax relief on the loan.

Tax on the home you live in. Under the Income-tax Act, 2025, the annual value of a house is the rent figure the tax law works from. It is taken as nil if the owner lives in it, for up to two houses you choose, and not if you let it out at any time in the year.

Tax relief on the loan. Under the old regime only, interest on a home loan for a home you live in is deductible up to ₹2,00,000 a year under section 22 (the old Section 24(b)). The house must be bought or built with borrowed money and finished within five years of the end of the year you borrowed. Principal repaid counts within section 123 (the old Section 80C), up to ₹1,50,000 in total, old regime only. If you sell within five years of the end of the year you got possession, those old-regime deductions are added back to your income. Home loan tax benefits has the detail.

Selling. A capital gain is the profit when you sell something for more than it cost you. For land and buildings, a gain is short-term if you held the property for not more than 24 months.

For a resident selling a house or land bought before 23 July 2024, tax is worked out two ways, one of them adjusted for inflation, and the lower figure is paid. Property bought on 23 July 2024 or later is taxed at a flat 12.5% on a long-term gain. Unlike long-term gains on equity shares and equity funds, property gains get no ₹1,25,000 tax-free allowance.

One relief is worth knowing. Under section 82 of the Income-tax Act, 2025 (the old Section 54), the gain on selling a house escapes tax if you put it into another house: bought within one year before or two years after the sale, or built within three years.

Renting vs buying: how do you work out which costs less?

Compare what each side spends that never comes back, and what each side builds. The renter spends rent and builds an investment pot. The buyer spends loan interest and owning costs and builds a flat, less what is still owed on the loan.

Here is one example. Hema and Jatin, in Indore, are choosing between buying a flat and renting a similar one. Every figure below is an assumption for the example, not market data.

AssumptionValue
Flat price₹75,00,000
Down payment₹15,00,000 (20%, the least a bank needs for a ₹60 lakh loan under the July 2026 rules above)
Home loan₹60,00,000 at an assumed 8.5% a year for 20 years
Rent for a similar flat₹22,000 a month, held flat
Return on money invested insteadan assumed 10% a year, also shown at 8%

Year one of buying. The EMI is ₹52,069 a month. In the first year about ₹5,05,419 of what Hema and Jatin pay is interest and about ₹1,19,409 is principal. Over the full 20 years they would pay ₹1,24,96,560, of which ₹64,96,560 is interest.

Year one of renting. The rent comes to ₹2,64,000. Interest and rent are both money that does not come back. The principal is different, because it builds ownership.

Where each side stands after ten years. On the buying side, about ₹41,99,703 of the loan is still owed.

On the renting side, the renters put the ₹15,00,000 down payment into an investment once, and they also invest the monthly difference. That difference is ₹52,069 minus ₹22,000, which is ₹30,069 a month. A SIP is investing a fixed amount at regular intervals, and a lumpsum is one larger payment made at one time. At an assumed 10% a year:

  • the lumpsum grows to about ₹38,90,614;
  • the SIP of ₹30,069 a month grows to about ₹62,10,813 on ₹36,08,280 put in;
  • together, about ₹1,01,01,426.

So buying comes out level only if the flat, less the ₹41,99,703 still owed, is worth what the renter has built. On these assumptions, the flat would need to be worth about ₹1.43 crore in ten years for buying to come out level with renting and investing the difference. At an assumed 8%, the SIP reaches about ₹55,37,678 and the lumpsum about ₹32,38,387, and the level value falls to about ₹1.30 crore.

That ₹1.43 crore is not a forecast of what the flat will fetch, and not advice to do either. Change the rent, the loan rate or the return, and the answer moves.

The sum leaves out stamp duty, registration, maintenance, property tax, rent increases, tax relief on the loan, selling costs and tax on the investments. Add them and the figures change. The assumed returns are only assumptions: investments can fall in value, and past performance may or may not be sustained in future.

Put your own numbers in the home loan calculator, the SIP calculator and the lumpsum calculator.

Is buying a flat to rent out a good investment?

It depends on how much rent is left after costs, how many months the flat stands empty, and the tax, set against what the same money could earn elsewhere.

Take the same ₹75,00,000 flat let at ₹22,000 a month. It brings ₹2,64,000 a year before costs, which is 3.52% of the price. That figure is the rental yield, the yearly rent as a share of the price. It is arithmetic on this example, not a market rate. Maintenance, property tax and the months without a tenant come out of it, and so does tax.

Rent from a house you let out is taxed under the head "Income from house property", one of the categories the Act sorts income into. The annual value is the higher of the rent the house could fetch and the rent actually received or receivable. The municipal taxes you actually paid in the year come off. Then 30% of the annual value and the loan interest are deducted.

Under the old regime only, a loss on a let-out house can be set off up to ₹2,00,000 against income under other heads, and the rest is carried forward for up to eight tax years against house-property income only. Under the new (default) regime, the interest can cut the rental income down to nil, but any excess is lost.

To weigh a flat against other ways of earning from property, read real estate vs equity investment and REIT vs physical real estate. For REITs themselves, see REITs in India.

What matters besides money?

Owning gives you security of tenure, the right to change the home as you wish, and no landlord who can raise the rent or ask you to leave. Renting keeps you free to move and leaves your money spread out instead of sitting in one building.

None of that has a rupee value in the sum above, and this article does not weigh it for you. Whether you are ready to buy is a separate question, taken up in signs you are ready to buy a house.

How can you save for a down payment?

Decide the amount and the date, start early, and choose where to keep the money by how far away the date is.

If you need the money within five years, short-term investing covers where such money can sit. The SIP calculator shows what a monthly amount could grow to on a return you assume.

You can start a SIP or one-time investment from ₹100 in the Koshex app. Koshex, as a distributor, helps you choose a fund that suits your goal and timeline. Browse mutual funds to see what is on offer.

Frequently asked questions

Is buying a house a good investment?
A house you live in is partly an investment and partly a cost of living. It saves you rent and its price may rise or fall. Loan interest, stamp duty, maintenance and property tax all take a share, so the answer depends on your own numbers.
Is renting a waste of money?
Rent pays for a place to live, as loan interest and maintenance do for an owner. In the worked example, a renter invests the down payment and the monthly difference. At an assumed 10%, that builds about ₹1.01 crore in ten years. That is an assumption, and investments can fall in value.
What tax benefits come with a home loan under 80C and 24(b)?
Under the old regime only, principal repaid and stamp duty count within the ₹1,50,000 limit of section 123. That is clawed back if you sell within five years of the end of the possession year. Under the old regime only, interest on a home you live in is deductible up to ₹2,00,000 a year under section 22. The house must be finished within five years of the end of the year you borrowed. The new regime allows neither for a home you live in. For a let-out home, interest can still cut its rent to nil, but any excess is lost.
What extra costs come with buying a house?
Stamp duty and registration come on top of the price. Both are set by each state, so check your state's registration department for the current rate. If the price is ₹50 lakh or more, you deduct 1% TDS and pay it to the government.
Is buying a house a good investment if I may sell within five years?
Buying costs are paid up front, and selling has its own costs. A house sold within 24 months of purchase gives a short-term gain. It is added to your income and taxed at your slab rate. Under the old regime only, section 123 deductions for the house's principal, stamp duty and registration are added back to your income. That happens if you sell within five years of the end of the year you got possession.
Is buying a second home a good investment?
For tax, the annual value of a home you live in is nil for up to two houses you choose. A home you let out is taxed on its rent as income from house property. Our home loan tax article covers the loan rules.
Is a house a safe investment?
No investment is free of risk. House prices can fall. A house can also put much of a family's money into one building.
Is buying a house better than investing in stocks or mutual funds?
A house needs a large down payment and brings costs such as maintenance and property tax. Our article on real estate versus equity sets the two side by side.

Try it on Koshex