What is risk tolerance, and how is it different from risk capacity?
Risk tolerance is how big a fall in your investments you can sit through without selling. It is about willingness. Risk capacity, a different thing, is how big a fall your finances can take. Knowing both before you invest is what stops a market fall from turning into a real loss.
In this guide
Key takeaways
- Risk tolerance is how big a fall you can sit through without selling, in rupees and in nerves.
- Risk capacity is a separate thing: how big a fall your finances can take without hurting a goal.
- Risk appetite is mostly used to mean the same as tolerance, and a risk profile is the label a questionnaire gives you.
- When tolerance and capacity differ, the lower one sets your limit, and money needed soon cannot wait out a fall.
- A questionnaire is a starting point, so redo it when your income, family or goal dates change.
What is risk tolerance?
Risk tolerance is how big a fall in your investments you can sit through without selling, in rupees and in nerves. It is about willingness. Your finances may be able to take a fall that you cannot stomach, and the reverse can also be true.
Here is a way to test yours. An index is a list of companies picked by fixed rules, whose combined value is tracked every day. The NIFTY Midcap 150 follows mid cap companies, those ranked 101 to 250 by market size. It closed at 6,792.20 on 7 February 2020. Six weeks later, on 23 March 2020, its close of 4,165.90 was 38.7% lower.
Turn that into your own money. ₹2,00,000 that tracked this index from the first date would have shown about ₹1,22,667 on the second. This is past index data from NSE Indices, not a fund and not a forecast. Ask yourself one thing: could you have watched that number without selling?
Why does risk tolerance matter?
A fall on screen becomes a real loss only when you sell. If you know your limit before the market drops, you are less likely to find it out in the middle of one.
SEBI's investor website describes a smart investor as one who "will not panic and sell their investments when the market takes a downturn." AMFI says investors "should not invest in the equity schemes unless they can afford to take the risk of possible loss of principal." Equity schemes are funds that invest mainly in shares of companies, and principal is the money you put in. Both say the same thing: know what you can bear before a fall, not during one.
How is risk tolerance different from risk capacity and risk appetite?
Risk tolerance is how much risk you are willing to take, risk capacity is how much your finances can afford to take, and risk appetite is mostly another word for tolerance. A fourth term, risk profile, is the label a questionnaire gives you from your answers.
| Term | What it measures | The question it answers |
|---|---|---|
| Risk tolerance | Your willingness: how big a fall you can sit through without selling | "Could I watch my money drop by a third and stay put?" |
| Risk capacity | Your ability: how big a fall your finances can take without hurting a goal, given income, dependants, emergency money and time to the goal | "If this money fell, could I still pay for the goal?" |
| Risk appetite | Often used to mean the same as risk tolerance | The same question as tolerance |
| Risk profile | The label a questionnaire gives you, for example conservative, moderate or aggressive | "What did my answers add up to?" |
The two that really differ are tolerance and capacity. Someone with a steady salary and no dependants may have high capacity but a nervous temperament. Someone who loves the market may have a family to support and a school fee due next year. When the two disagree, the lower one sets your limit.
SEBI draws the same line in its own words. Its rules for registered investment advisers speak of the risk a client is "willing and able to take", and they ask for an assessment of the client's "capacity for absorbing loss". The pair "risk tolerance" and "risk capacity" are not SEBI's phrases, but the split is.
What decides your risk tolerance?
Four things move your limit: time to the goal, income and who depends on it, money set aside, and how you have reacted to falls before. The first three are about your risk capacity. The last is about your tolerance.
Time to the goal. Time horizon is how long until you need the money. As a goal comes closer, there is less time for a fall to recover before you need the money. This is why some investors move money from equity towards debt in the last few years before a goal, and why SEBI's life cycle funds reduce their equity share as the target date nears. Life cycle funds are funds built around a set target date. Debt means loans to governments, banks or companies. As one example of how horizons differ by fund, Koshex suggests 7 years or more for small cap funds. These invest mainly in companies ranked 251 onwards by size.
Income and dependants. A steady income lets you leave investments alone through a bad year. People who depend on that income make a sudden shortfall harder to absorb.
Emergency money. Keep money aside for emergencies before you invest, so that a sudden expense does not force a sale when prices are low. A common size is three to six months of expenses, as explained in where to keep your emergency savings.
Past reactions. If you sold in a past fall and regretted it, that is information about your tolerance. If you held and slept fine, that is information too. Tolerance is a feeling, and experience shapes it.
Age matters here only as a stand-in for time and income. It is not a rule. The "100 minus your age" idea is covered in how asset allocation impacts your portfolio.
What do conservative, moderate and aggressive mean?
They are labels for how much short-term fall a person accepts in return for the chance of more growth. They describe the person, not a list of things to buy.
- Conservative: the person accepts only a small fall in value, and gives up some chance of growth for it.
- Moderate: the person accepts a medium fall for more chance of growth.
- Aggressive: the person accepts a large fall for a greater chance of growth.
The label describes you, not your goal. How soon you need the money still matters, whatever your label says.
How does your profile match a fund's riskometer?
Your profile belongs to you. The riskometer belongs to the fund. SEBI makes every fund show one, on six levels: Low, Low to Moderate, Moderate, Moderately High, High and Very High, checked every month.
SEBI also requires every fund to carry a product label that starts "This product is suitable for investors who are seeking". It says in a line what the fund is for and roughly how long it suits. Matching means reading both against your own profile and your goal date. The fund-side view is in how to choose the right mutual fund for your goals and the long-term portfolio guide.
How is risk tolerance measured?
A common way is a risk-profile questionnaire. It asks about your situation and how you would react to a fall, and turns the answers into a profile.
SEBI has written down what such an assessment must cover, for registered investment advisers. They must judge both how much risk you are willing to take and how much you are able to take, including how big a loss you could absorb. They must ask about your age, goals and how long you can stay invested. Income, existing investments, borrowings and your comfort with risk are on the list too. They must update it from time to time. The questionnaire itself must be "fair, clear and not misleading", and the profile is communicated to the client.
Those are SEBI's rules for investment advisers. Separately, the Koshex app runs a risk-profile questionnaire. It is free.
Treat the result as a starting point, not a verdict. A questionnaire cannot see a school fee next year unless you tell it, so look at your own goals beside the label. Redo it when life changes: a new job, a child, a loan, a goal that has moved closer.
What if your risk tolerance and your goal do not match?
The goal date and your capacity win. Money you need in two years cannot wait out a fall, however calm you feel. A fall like the Midcap 150's in 2020 does not wait for your goal date.
The reverse also happens. A goal 15 years away with a low tolerance leaves two options. One is a smaller share in equity. The other is learning what past falls looked like until they feel less frightening.
How much to hold in each is a decision about your allocation. Pure equity versus asset allocation compares the two approaches, and moving between equity and debt looks at when a goal date changes the picture.
Koshex talks you through sharp market falls before you redeem (sell your units). The reasons people sell, and what it costs them, are in should I redeem my funds since the markets are down.
Where does fund risk fit in?
This page is about you. How a fund can lose money, how to measure that and how to reduce it are separate topics. What are the risks involved in mutual funds lists the kinds of risk, five ways to measure mutual fund risk covers the measures, and top strategies to reduce mutual fund risk covers what you can do about it. The mid cap funds page sets out what SEBI's mid cap category must hold.